Monday, 29 February 2016

To the future!



We are a shul with a history – and we are also a shul with a future. That future was the theme of Rabbi Laura Janner-Klausner’s visit to Jackson’s Row yesterday. As our rebuilding draws ever closer, we gathered together to share our visions about our new home, and to be inspired by our very inspirational Senior Rabbi.
Laura started by asking us who we all were. What emerged from that was a picture of a hugely committed, caring community – diverse but united in their hopes for our synagogue. Some members were born into the synagogue, others were on the conversion course, about to join. Others have given a lifetime of service to the synagogue, others were brimming with enthusiasm to do just that. People led services, prepared kiddushes, did security duty, looked after our web presence, sang in the choir, ran family services, did outreach work – not to mention the President and his team who are working tirelessly on finalising the new build. Laura was – to coin a phrase – quite gobsmacked. She said our loyalty and continuity was something very special. As indeed it is!
We then all talked about our new building, and how we saw our community in the future. We all agreed we want a beacon synagogue – a building which has prayer at its heart, but also will be the go-to place for city-working and city-dwelling Jews. Laura stressed how we can exploit our position in the city centre, and encouraged us to think of the new opportunities change will bring. She said we can be a magnet for Jewish life in Manchester.
What’s not in any doubt is that our new building will allow us to do so much more than we can do at present. We will be able to hold all sorts of events, cater for members and guests, house learning resources and – ta-dah! – be able to park! The future looks very, very bright.
We also talked about the interim period, when we’ll be without a synagogue building. Danny, our President, made it clear that a lot of sound arrangements were already in place, and that we will continue worshipping in the city centre and also that Rabbi and Mandy will have offices here. And of course, Friday night services can be held in homes. As indeed they were last Shabbat – we had services in both North and South Manchester which attracted 10 times as many congregants as usual – a big thank you to Sharon and Brendan and Isabel and Peter for lending us their homes.
Even if we don’t have a permanent synagogue building for a while, it became very clear from Rabbi Laura’s meeting with us that we have the desire to keep our community life alive in the interim, and will more than rise to the challenge of being in transit. Rebuilding? No problem - we’ve done this before!  And Danny and the Rabbi were also able to assure us that the most treasured artefacts of our sanctuary will be moving with us to our temporary home.
A huge thank you to Rabbi Laura, and kol hakavod to all of us. To the future!

Sunday, 7 February 2016

Jewsih Book Week in the north



For the keen readers among you, here’s the lowdown on Jewish Book Week. For the second year running, Jewish Book Week is coming up north (hooray!) 

Our sister shul, Menorah, is privileged to be hosting Wendy Holden and Eve Clarke. Wendy Holden is the author of 'Born Survivors', an account of how three mothers and their newborns fought to survive the Nazi regime. Eve Clarke was born at the gates of Mauthausen Concentration Camp in 1945. Her pregnant mother had survived both a journey to Auschwitz11-Birkenau and the scrutiny of Joseph Mengele.

Wendy and Eva are in conversation with Gita Conn on Sunday February 28th at 6.00 pm

At 8.00 pm , also on the 28th Feb ( there is a bagel break between the two!)  Menorah is delighted to be hosting Saul David, historian and broadcaster, who will be talking about Operation Thunderbolt, Flight 139 and the Raid on Entebbe. In 1976 a group of German and Palestinian terrorists hijacked an Air France flight from Tel Aviv to Paris, eventually forcing it to land in Uganda. This fast-paced account of the hijacking, details the daring and ultra-secret mission orchestrated by the Israeli government to save the hostages and end the terror.

To book visit http://menorah.org.uk/jbw/ or call 0161 428 7746.

Also note other events include Wednesday 2nd March at Yeshurun Synagogue (Tel: 0161 428 8242) -   Dan Stone discusses The Liberation of the Camps – 8pm. And on Sunday 6th March at Bowdon Synagogue ( with Hale Synagogue) (Tel:0161 928 2050) Colin Shindler discusses The Rise of the Israeli Right: from Odessa to Hebron 6pm and at 8pm Thomas Harding discusses The House by the Lake

 You can book at http://www.jewishbookweek.com/events/jewish-book-week-tour or contact the numbers above.

Monday, 18 January 2016

Jewish Perspectives on the Junior Doctors' Strike

Here's Rabbi's Silverman's talk from the Bimah regarding the Junior Doctors' strike. There are some useful links, both for and against, at the bottom.



I want to say a bit about this week’s Junior Doctors’ Strike. It’s impossible to avoid being political, and I have to declare a personal interest: our son and daughter in law are both junior hospital doctors and our granddaughter of 9 months joins in with the campaign song. I‘ve listened to the feelings which some of you have had as patients. But there are Jewish ethical and spiritual points to be made.

English doctors on Tuesday staged their first strike in 40 years over government plans to reform pay and conditions for working unsocial hours.  The Junior doctors delivered emergency care during the 24-hour walkout.

No change resulted, so the doctors are planning a 48-hr strike later this month. The government have threatened to make a new working contract compulsory.

The key issue is having to work longer hours at weekends with Saturdays being regarded as part of the normal working week. So for us there is an issue about Shabbat. Instead of our son’s working day starting at 7am and finishing at 7pm the demand is to continue working until 10pm: 15 hours at a stretch. And especially at weekends their baby daughter misses out on prime time.

There is of course a pay issue: the hours for which they are currently paid a premium would be considered to be standard.  The doctors’ union, the British Medical Association said the contract does not provide proper safeguards against doctors working dangerously long hours. The government is saying that the doctors’ hours over a 7 day week will be reduced from 91 to 76 hours. But the Junior doctors’ concern is about weekend working.

I’m not going to argue the case for the doctors; there’s plenty being said on both sides from which you can make up your own mind.

I want to look at it from a Jewish point of view. Given that this is about extra time at weekends it is a subject most relevant to the principle of rest on Shabbat. Halachah permits doctors to work on Shabbat. Indeed, if it is a matter of saving life, they are obliged to work on Shabbat, both by the Hippocratic oath which they swear on graduating and by halachah and Jewish ethics.

In Israel doctors’ strikes are not uncommon; there were a series of them 5 years ago which totalled 127 days. How did the rabbis react? Most of the authoritative Israeli rabbinate are opposed on principle: doctors should not go on strike because they are involved in pikkuach nefesh, saving life.

But a section of the orthodox rabbinate in Israel has taken an opposing view.  Their argument was based on the same halachic principle: "Saving a life overrides the entire Torah," the rabbis said. “Long hours put patients' lives at risk.”

There’s another side to it from the doctor’s point of view. Having to work long hours especially at weekends is not family friendly.

The problem of doctors having to work on Shabbat  - and most have always  done, is overcome by the famous advice of Leo Baeck to fellow prisoners in the concentration camp. If you cannot have a Shabbat day, aim for Shabbat hours.

And behind the whole issue is a principle summed up in a little rhyme that is said and also sung in Israel (composed by a 16th century Italian doctor David ben Shelomo HaRofe). It’s about the worry of losing financially, preoccupying people more than losing prime time.  The rhyme is based on similarity of sound Damav – one’s money (dam means blood, money is lifeblood;) Yamav is one’s time: yom day, yamav one’s days, one’s life. Damav- yamav.

It goes like this.

אדם דואג על אבוד דמיו ואינו דואג על אבוד ימיו. 
ימיו אינם חוזרים
דמיו אינם עוזרים




Adam doeg al ibbud damav, ve’eyno doeg al ibbud yamav.

Damav eynam ozrim yamav eynam chozrim.

Here’s my paraphrase translation

People dread their loss of pay; much more than they'd miss the loss of a day.

Your pay you can always earn; your days will not return.

…………………










Against:  Fred Rosner


Against: Jerusalem Post

o    Cached
Rabbi Jonathan Rosenblum. The 127-day doctors' strike in Israel finally came to an end last week. The number of lives lost in the course of the strike is still to be ...


Pro –protest orthx Rabbis in Israel 08.03.11 

Wednesday, 6 January 2016

Rain? What rain!

Despite floods and incessant rain, the Jackson's Row ramble went ahead as planned. No one is more indefatigable than Joyce Goodman, our leader, who having being flooded herself, turned up bright and breezy to lead us through Ramsbottom and its environs. And by 'us', I mean 10 of us - and Hermione, the Taylor dog.
The ramble was re-routed to avoid flood damage and so we ascended to Grants' Tower - a now ruined historical sight, marking the place where the Grant Brothers first saw the valley of Ramsbottom and decided to settle there. They became mill owners and philanthropists - Charles Dickens was inspired by them to create the Cheeryble Brothers in Nicholas Nickleby.
I like to think Dickens might have been inspired by us sodden ramblers too. Here we are - at least, those of us who were dry enough to be photographed.


As we enter into the secular year 2016 and await our rebuild, it's good to know that JR has the community spirit to triumph in any circumstances!

Monday, 14 December 2015

And for our next thing ....

We brought Just One Thing to a grand conclusion with our wonderful Chanukah party yesterday afternoon. Rabbi gave a fascinating shiur on synagogue buildings - apparently the essential thing for a synagogue is not a Torah Scroll, or ark or kiddush (shame!) but people - the minyan is the thing. We certainly had more than a minyan yesterday.
Aimee and David entertained the young ones ...


While the older ones amused themselves with some Israeli dancing led by Cathy Knowles ..





And the doughnuts and latkes were eaten by everyone.

In fact, the party was so good that plans were hatched to do something similar at Purim, and some of us will also be meeting on Jan 3rd for a post-Bank Holiday ramble. 
Thank you to everyone who did Just One Thing, and also to those who did many, many things!



Monday, 7 December 2015

JUST ONE THING



Happy Chanukah!
Don’t we all love lighting the first candle, knowing that it’s only going to get better and brighter as each night adds another flame?
It’s the same with shul’s Just One Thing.
Last Tuesday for her Just One Thing, Mandy organised a shul night out, and it was fantastic – an excellent turn out, lively conversation, and off the back of it, plans for a blow-away-the festive-cobwebs ramble on January 3rd. Watch this space!
On Shabbat, David Hoffman’s One Thing involved bringing Shir Chadash to the Shabbat morning service. (And a big mazeltov to David, on becoming the new Chairperson of Limmud!) Downstairs, just off the Alexander Levy Hall, we were treated to a musical service, complete with guitar, mandolin, piano and voice. The essential components of the Shabbat service are all there – the key prayers, the Torah reading, Haftarah, but delivered creatively and interactively. It’s a different and refreshing way of worship.
And if you’re sad you missed it, don’t be! Because there’s a special Shir Chadash service this Friday night complete with doughnuts and a chavurah supper. Details from Mandy in the shul office.
Whether you’ve done your One Thing or not, be sure to come to the Just One Thing grand finale – our spectacular Chanukah Party this Sunday 13th December, 3 – 6pm at shul. It’s free and there’s something to suit everyone – a shiur from Rabbi, games for children and ... ta-dah! ... doughnuts! Give Mandy a ring if you can, to say you’ll be there, but the most important thing is to turn up.
And remember to check the Just One Thing Facebook page, and tell us what you’ve done! Sh’choyach to Jay, for setting this up as his Just One Thing!
(And mazeltov to Richard and Amal, who got married for their Just One Thing. Beat that!)